Blog
Business Valuation for Estate and Probate: How Date-of-Death Appraisals Differ From Other Business Valuations
Business valuation for estate and probate is built around the date of death, the IRC 2032 alternate valuation election, and a hypothetical-market standard. This guide shows how that differs from gift, sale, and divorce valuations so you know what your report must contain.
Published
A business valuation for estate and probate answers a narrower, more rule-bound question than most business appraisals: what was this ownership interest worth on a specific legal date, measured by a specific legal standard? The wrong date, the wrong interest, or the wrong standard can undo an otherwise careful analysis. This guide explains how date-of-death valuation works, how the alternate valuation election fits in, and where estate and probate work parts ways from gift, sale, and divorce valuations.
If you are an executor or advisor facing a closely held company in an estate, our business valuation for estate tax service covers the federal filing side. Here we focus on why these engagements are different.
What Makes an Estate or Probate Business Valuation Different?
An estate or probate valuation is tied to a legal event (death), a fixed valuation date, and a defined standard of value. Most other business appraisals are tied to a transaction, a dispute, or a planning goal, so the date and the buyer assumptions come from the deal rather than from statute.
For federal estate tax, property is generally valued at fair market value on the decedent's date of death. Treasury Regulation 20.2031-1 defines that as the price at which property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither under compulsion and both having reasonable knowledge of the relevant facts. The buyer and seller are hypothetical. The price a real buyer later pays, the book value on the balance sheet, and the owner's own opinion are all evidence at most, never the definition.
Three features set these engagements apart:
- A fixed historical date: Value is measured as of death (or the elected alternate date), so the analysis can only rely on what was known or reasonably knowable then.
- A specific interest: The report must value the interest the decedent actually owned, whether that is a controlling block, a minority stake, nonvoting shares, or a partnership or LLC interest.
- A reviewing audience: The report may be read by the IRS, a probate court, a fiduciary's attorney, and beneficiaries, so the support behind every assumption matters.
How Date-of-Death Valuation Works
Date-of-death valuation means the appraiser concludes value as of the day the owner died, using only information available or foreseeable on that day. Later events matter only if they reveal conditions that already existed at death.
This is where hindsight becomes a trap. A buyer may purchase the company 4 months after death for a price well above or below the appraised figure. That sale is relevant evidence, but our appraisers have to ask whether it was close in time, whether market conditions changed in between, whether the interest sold was comparable, and whether the deal included synergies or distress terms inconsistent with the hypothetical-market premise. A later sale does not automatically set the date-of-death value.
The federal return also drives the paperwork. The Form 706 instructions require the executor to report a best estimate of value and to attach supporting information for closely held business interests, such as financial statements and ownership details. Form 706 is generally due 9 months after death, with an automatic 6-month extension to file if properly requested. An extension to file does not extend the time to pay any tax.
Example: A founder dies on March 1 owning 40% of a manufacturing company. The report values that 40% interest as of March 1, based on the company's financial condition, outlook, and market evidence at that point. A customer loss in September is not reflected unless it was already foreseeable in March.
What Is the IRC 2032 Alternate Valuation Date Election?
The alternate valuation date election lets an executor value the estate's assets as of a date 6 months after death instead of the date of death. Property that is distributed, sold, or otherwise disposed of within those 6 months is valued as of its disposition date.
The election is available only under strict conditions, drawn from Internal Revenue Code section 2032 and the Form 706 instructions:
- It must lower both numbers: The election is allowed only if it reduces the value of the gross estate and also reduces the estate tax (plus any generation-skipping transfer tax) due.
- It is made on the return: The executor makes the election on a timely filed Form 706.
- It is all or nothing: The election applies to the estate as a whole, so you cannot pick the alternate date for some assets and the date of death for others.
- It is generally not revocable: Once made, it cannot be undone without IRS consent.
Key takeaway: The executor, not the appraiser, makes this election. Our role is to deliver defensible values at each date the executor may need, so the decision can be made with real numbers in hand.
Because the election only helps when values fall, it is most relevant when market conditions or company performance deteriorate after death. If values rose, the election is typically unavailable because it would not reduce the estate tax.
How Closely Held Interests Are Valued in an Estate
Closely held business interests are valued using the factors in Revenue Ruling 59-60 and the governing Treasury regulations. Treasury Regulation 20.2031-3 calls for a fair appraisal of the business's tangible and intangible assets, its demonstrated earning capacity, and other relevant factors, while Treasury Regulation 20.2031-2 addresses stock where no market quotations exist.
Revenue Ruling 59-60 directs the appraiser to consider these factors:
- The nature and history of the business
- The economic outlook and the outlook for the specific industry
- The book value of the stock and the financial condition of the business
- The earning capacity of the company
- The dividend-paying capacity of the company
- Goodwill and other intangible value
- Prior sales of the stock and the size of the block being valued
- Prices of stock in comparable publicly traded companies
No single formula applies. Our appraisers typically weigh the income, market, and asset approaches, then reconcile them to the specific interest. Our appraisers hold credentials with leading organizations such as the ASA and NACVA, and every report is prepared in accordance with USPAP, published by The Appraisal Foundation.
Discounts for Lack of Control and Marketability
Discounts for lack of control and lack of marketability apply when the facts support them, not by rule of thumb. A 30% minority stake in a family company usually cannot force distributions, a sale, or a change in management, and no ready public market exists for it. Those characteristics belong in the analysis, but each percentage has to be backed by transaction data, restricted-stock evidence, or other support specific to the interest. We explain the mechanics in our guide to how lack of marketability and minority interest discounts are determined.
Watch out: Applying a control-level multiple to a minority interest overstates value. Ignoring the interest's actual rights can understate it. Either error invites scrutiny.
Estate and Probate vs. Gift, Sale, and Divorce Valuations
Estate and probate valuations differ from other business appraisals in valuation date, standard of value, governing authority, and who relies on the report. The same company can have several defensible values for different purposes, and none of them is wrong if each applies the correct rules.
The table below compares the four common assignment types:
| Factor | Estate / Probate | Gift | Sale | Divorce |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Valuation date | Date of death, or the alternate date 6 months later if elected | Date of the gift | Anticipated or actual closing date | Set by state law or court order (often separation, filing, or trial) |
| Standard of value | Fair market value (hypothetical willing buyer and seller) | Fair market value | Negotiated price; investment or strategic value | Fair market value or fair value, depending on the state |
| Governing authority | IRC 2031 and 2032, Treasury regulations, Rev. Rul. 59-60; state probate law | IRC 2512 and Treasury gift tax regulations | Contract and market negotiation | State marital property statutes and case law |
| Who relies on the report | Executor, IRS, probate court, beneficiaries | Donor, donee, IRS | Buyer, seller, lenders | Spouses, attorneys, court |
Gift valuations come closest to estate work because both use fair market value. The gift tax rules in Treasury Regulations Part 25 measure value on the date of the gift, so no alternate date exists and no election is involved. A sale valuation, by contrast, may reflect a specific buyer's synergies and financing, which the hypothetical-market standard does not automatically allow.
Divorce is the most variable. Some states use fair market value, others use fair value, and the treatment of discounts and personal goodwill differs by jurisdiction. The valuation date can also differ from state to state.
How Probate Valuations Differ From Federal Estate Tax Valuations
Probate valuation is governed by state law, so it is not a single nationwide standard. A probate court may require an appraisal to inventory estate assets, determine what beneficiaries receive, allocate an interest among heirs, or resolve a buyout under an operating agreement. A federal return may not be required at all.
Because the controlling rules come from the state statute, court order, or governing document, the engagement letter should state the exact question being answered. Calling the work a probate valuation without naming the legal purpose leaves too much room for the wrong date or standard. When both a federal return and a probate filing are involved, we flag any place where the two sets of rules could produce different values.
Why File Form 706 Even When the Estate Is Under the Exemption?
Filing Form 706 below the filing threshold can still be worthwhile, because it can support a stepped-up basis for heirs and start the 3-year statute of limitations on the reported values. For decedents dying in 2026, the federal basic exclusion amount is $15,000,000, as described in the IRS estate tax guidance. Many estates fall below that, but a closely held business can push a family closer to the line than expected.
A documented, supportable appraisal gives heirs a defensible basis if they later sell the business interest. It also gives the executor a record if the IRS questions the reported value. Filing can also be required to elect portability of a deceased spouse's unused exclusion. That decision belongs to the executor and the estate's tax advisor.
What Drives the Cost and Scope of an Estate Business Valuation?
Scope drives fees: the complexity of the entity, the quality and completeness of the records, the number of entities or interests, and the depth of analysis required. Intended use matters too, since a report built for IRS filing carries more documentation than a standard one. Value-side facts, such as how large the business is worth, change the concluded value, not what the appraisal costs.
Our business valuation fees start at $4,500 for standard reporting and $5,500 for advanced, IRS-qualified reporting. Every engagement is a fixed fee quoted before work begins, never billed hourly. Clean financial statements, the governing documents, and any buy-sell agreements help us scope the work accurately.
Getting the Valuation Right the First Time
Estate and probate valuations reward early, precise scoping. Confirm the legal purpose, the valuation date, and the exact interest being valued before the analysis begins. Let the executor decide on the alternate valuation election with both sets of values in front of them, and make sure the report addresses the specific rights of the interest owned.
If you are handling an estate that includes a closely held company, you can request an appraisal and our team will scope a fixed-fee valuation built for your filing or court requirement.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Readers should consult a qualified attorney or CPA regarding their specific circumstances.
